1 (edited by Umbramatic 2012-06-17 18:14:35)

Topic: Umbra's Polls: #1: WHAT A TWEEST!

Yeah, I'm gonna start putting any ideas I have for feedback polls on my characters here in the testing forum. Today's poll subject: Plot twists!

I'm gonna ask everyone to pick from a list of plot twists and such I've used for my characters and decide on their favorites. Respond here, or, if you don't have a testing forum account, in the chat.

Also, I would let people pick based on the normal criteria of how surprising it was (since that's much of a plot twist's point)... But, considering how I've spoiled almost every one of my twists for planning purposes, I'd prefer if people voted based on other criteria, because otherwise Gino's would get all the votes :P. Thank you.

And now, for the contenders!



Umbra and Lina's Origins (Tagg, Mind)

Umbra's ties to Ransei (Tagg, Crewe)

Styx's backstory (Rex, Tangent, Sixth, ,Tagg, Mezzo)

Axel's backstory (Crewe)

Chrome's backstory (Tracer,* Tagg)

Gino's backstory (Eskay, Tracer* [with a honrable mention from Silent])

Ammy's parentage (Silent, Every)

AU!Alduin (Luke, Pika)

Any I'm missing.

* Tracer initially picked just Gino's, but when I asked him to remove spoilerage from the consideration, he tied Gino and Chrome.

Happy voting, and make sure if you have a reason WHY something is your favorite, to include it in your response.

My girlfriend is a Volcarona, your argument is invalid.

2

Re: Umbra's Polls: #1: WHAT A TWEEST!

I vote Styx's backstory for the Heartwarming.

Nyaaa

3

Re: Umbra's Polls: #1: WHAT A TWEEST!

Favourite plot twist: Ammy's parentage, paws down. Relatively strong contender: Gino's backstory, nya~ :3

Rationale: despite the fact that it was (more or less, compared to eg.: Styx's backstory) fairly promoted in development stage, it managed to keep a quite strong sense of twistness and of (out-of-universe) lector teasing. Also I feel it is the twist that helps extend its character the most of all the ones in the list ecept perhaps Axel's backstory, but unlike Axel's this one felt better integrated to the ongoing storyline.

As for Gino, come on, there you have a Salamence who acts like a kitty. How can you not love that to the point of wondering how such a weird cuteness was even possible in universe? And the answer, once found, makes so much sense for the kind of world we're playing with.

(Besides, it gets extra points because it does fit nicely with the perception of the character when he noms Rattatas whole, nyan~)

Thou hast forgotten the face of thy Lord. Remember, mortal, and fear pet me.

4

Re: Umbra's Polls: #1: WHAT A TWEEST!

Gino's backstory, nyan!

[Spectrum was here!]

5

Re: Umbra's Polls: #1: WHAT A TWEEST!

AMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMYAMMY

...Did I mention that I liked the reveal of Ammy's parentage?

6

Re: Umbra's Polls: #1: WHAT A TWEEST!

Updated the list with the votes of everyone so far.

My girlfriend is a Volcarona, your argument is invalid.

7

Re: Umbra's Polls: #1: WHAT A TWEEST!

-a Dunsparce wearing glasses and a fake nose enters the thread-

Uh...hey. I'm...um....Yreve Otimem. I think Ammy's reveal was really cool. Um...yeah.

-flees-

8

Re: Umbra's Polls: #1: WHAT A TWEEST!

…Every, we know it's you :P

Nyaaa

9

Re: Umbra's Polls: #1: WHAT A TWEEST!

I think my favorites would be #1, #2, #3, and #5.

10

Re: Umbra's Polls: #1: WHAT A TWEEST!

Are you kidding? I'm just mild-mannered Every Memito. THAT was Yreve Otimem. I don't understand how you could possibly get us mixed up.

11

Re: Umbra's Polls: #1: WHAT A TWEEST!

Alduin :3

12

Re: Umbra's Polls: #1: WHAT A TWEEST!

I think I'd have to say Styx's backstory. Yes, I had major input on Ammy's parentage, but it's not quite my favorite twist.

13

Re: Umbra's Polls: #1: WHAT A TWEEST!

Gotta go with Umbra and Lina's origins. The original, the best in my mind, and moreover the one I've seen played with most and have the most potential for stories. I like open ideas like this, so it gets my vote.

Orchestrated Chaos... A symphony to live by.

14

Re: Umbra's Polls: #1: WHAT A TWEEST!

Okay, so I read the links you gave me, and I think I understand more or less all of it. So I have two favorites:

1) Umbra's ties to Ransei. It wasn't given all that much notice IRP that I could see, but the idea of Umbra (who is decidedly one of the good guys) became obsessed with conquest is interesting. I really hope it gets fleshed out later.

2) Axel's backstory. I've never played Kingdom Hearts, though I know it has something to do with Disney, and there are things called Heartless that were explained to me once several years ago but I forget how, and there's a sword shaped like a giant key for some reason. The reason I like this twist is the idea of a Pokemon becoming so obsessed with a game that they go to such lengths to act it out and make it real absolutely fascinates me. Also, "All according to the script" is a great villain line.

15

Re: Umbra's Polls: #1: WHAT A TWEEST!

Updated results again. We only need a couple more votes, I think!

My girlfriend is a Volcarona, your argument is invalid.